Tuesday, December 1, 2015

The Wal-Mart Economic Equation

Wal-Mart spreads like a disease gone mad and it's only governed by one thing:  so long as Wal-Mart gives the state more in sales tax on products than it takes through benefits (e.g. Food Stamps, etc) for underpaid workers, the state will never have a problem with anything Wal-Mart does.

The state also benefits strongly from taxation of Wal-Mart workers even though they are paid minimally for the services.  Even though these workers have full-time jobs and do jobs other people cannot do or are unwilling to do, Wal-Mart is one of the strongest opponents to an increase in the minimum wage.

The discussion of minimum wage is secondary because the state likely makes enough on sales tax on products sold at Wal-Mart that it doesn't care what the Waltons bleed off the workers.  If the minimum wage goes up then the state draws more money from taxing it but the Waltons scream like pigs.  If it stays the same, the state doesn't care because it makes bank from the sales tax anyway.


Discussion of minimum wage is important as a short-term consideration but it falls far short of the problem of why should sales tax exist at all.  Why should the consumer be punished in this way for investing in the economy either by obtaining the foods needed to stay healthy and productive or through buying products which results in stimulation of business and jobs elsewhere.

Consumption is a fundamental requirement of capitalism and yet consumers are punished in this way for doing it.  The state's response is generally simplistic insofar as, well, we couldn't think up a better way to handle appropriate taxation for the ongoing support of the state.  To that we reply, consider getting better accountants, some who actually know what they are doing this time (i.e. other than plundering the people).

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

WalMart will follow Sears Kmart. Amazon will spell thier doom.
I have to tenants that were hired by Amazon to pack boxes on Graveyard shift at $14.50/hr. With a $2/hr season bonus and presently working 55hours per week
That is about the same as 2 1/2 WalMart employees. Yes they do not have healthcare but they di receive a $10 per day gas card fir the 30 mile drive to work.
So why cant WalMart do the same. Because the Walton family would slip down the Forbes list

Unknown said...

I really don't think the actual Walton family even cares what it does since all of them are multi-billionaires so you all toddle off to take care of the business and send us money. Even if it collapses altogether, they will live in luxury. They have been getting away with it so long they have no particular reason to change. I'm glad to hear Amazon gives them one.

Anonymous said...

The family doesnt need to change but the company sure does along with most of the rest of them. And I am fairly conservative but when I have to hand hold and support so many kids trying to get on thier feet it really pisses me off when companies screw them
It also pisses me off when so many parents look at 18 year olds and say my job is done hope you make it.
This is a request for givernment support but community support. The old fashioned kind where you help those around you.

Unknown said...

Kannafoot takes a different position that failing to get ahead is due to poor personal decisions. That's an extreme reduction of it but that's the general view.

I agree an extended solution of some nature is needed because I really think social networks facilitate people conglobating into little what-me-worry balls which can easily ignore a great many things. Kannafoot is not one of that crew but a great many people are and I do think social networks exacerbate the tendency to wrap around yourself to the exclusion of everything else.

Anonymous said...

Kannafoot is correct. Usually it is poor position results from poor decisions.
But a minimum wage employee brings home
about $225 per week. That means they need to commune or work multiple jobs just to survive.
While a minimum wage is meant for 16 year old entering the job market and a ensuing climb results .
But for the multitude of people today with little education they are screwed to getting restarted

Anonymous said...

I have two living in my shed trying to get reestablished.
note. it is a pretty cool shed with lights heat a loft area for sleeping and is not much smaller than a studio apt

Unknown said...

That sounds like a highly excellent loft!

My biggest problem is in the consequence of a bad decision. There are any number which leave you screwed for life so it's one hell of a hard crash. For example, husband or bf walks and woman is left holding the baby. He's got at least some work experience but she doesn't so she goes to Wal-Mart. Her chance of working out of that job while still taking care of the kid is close to zero. I see that as one hell of a harsh punishment. I don't mean that as a case study but rather one more example of the naked city.